The softball team has a rich legacy at Berean. They are the only team in Berean history to win a state championship, doing so in 2004. They finished the year 28-1, defeating Cloverdale in the CIF-NCS finals 10-0 and earning the CalHi Division V #1 ranking to finish the season. The have three runner-up finishes in the CIF-NCS championships to go with their one win.
Many players have gone on to play softball at the college level, including six from that 2004 team.
Berean placed into the top division in the DAL based on their performance over the past two years.